THE SNAPSHOT
H漫画鈥檚 Dr. Christine Chambers and her colleagues at Solutions for Kids in Pain (SKIP) are working with hospitals to adopt Canada鈥檚 first Pediatric Pain Management Standard, giving institutions like Halifax鈥檚 IWK Health Centre tools and support to prevent and treat the chronic pain one in five Canadian children endure.
THE CHALLENGE
When Isabel Jordan鈥檚 oldest child was in hospital in outside of Atlantic Canada to remove a bone tumour in their jaw, she watched helplessly while nurses and doctors performed excruciatingly painful medical procedures on them, without sedation.
Alex, who is non-binary (pronouns they/them), has a rare genetic condition that includes a sensory processing disorder. After the surgery, Alex had a tracheostomy and could not speak.
Too little to write things down, the six-year-old was unable to tell the nurses and doctors how much it hurt to receive injections, have fluids delivered through intravenous therapy, or have a catheter inserted or removed.
When Isabel and Tyler Jordan tried to ask for sedation or other ways to treat their child鈥檚 pain, the hospital staff dismissed the couple鈥檚 concerns.
Isabel Jordan
鈥淭he doctors and nurses wouldn鈥檛 believe that the things they were doing, which they thought were no big deal, were actually horrifically painful for them,鈥� Ms. Jordan remembers. 鈥淲e didn鈥檛 have the tools to advocate for them.鈥�
The Jordans stationed themselves at Alex鈥檚 bedside day and night, eventually refusing permission for any procedures until staff had provided adequate pain relief for Alex.
THE SOLUTION
Eighteen years later, Ms. Jordan is working with Professor Christine Chambers, H漫画鈥檚 Canada Research Chair in Children鈥檚 Pain, to make sure hospitals and other healthcare organizations adopt the first national Pediatric Pain Management Standard.
The chronic pain children suffer is the reason Dr. Chambers and her colleagues at SKIP met in Halifax this past December. SKIP is a national knowledge mobilization network and a research centre at H漫画, for which she is the scientific director. The meeting鈥檚 goal was to develop an action plan to encourage health-care organizations to implement their new Pediatric Pain Management Standard鈥攊deally, as essential to their accreditation process.
SKIP established the standard with the Health Standards Organization, a global entity that works with leading experts and people with lived experience to develop standards, assessment programs and quality improvement solutions. Together, they developed 34 specific recommendations on how to deliver evidence-based, equitable, and person-centred pain care and support for children and youth.
Dr. Christine Chambers,聽Professor, Canada Research Chair (Tier 1) in Children's Pain at H漫画.
鈥淥ur goal is not to make pain management optional; our goal is to make it required,鈥� says Dr. Chambers.
The initiative is critically important because close to 21 per cent of children and youth around the world live with chronic pain, or one in five, according to a Dr. Chambers and her colleagues have just published.
Dr. Chambers and her co-authors analyzed the results of 119 studies from around the world. They found a higher percentage of girls than boys experience chronic pain, which can include headaches, back aches, abdominal pain, musculoskeletal pain, and generalized pain.
Discouragingly, says Dr. Chambers, the one in five figure is in line with what the last major review on children鈥檚 pain found in 2011.
鈥淒espite decades of research focused on addressing the problem of pain in children, children are still suffering,鈥� she says. 鈥淭hat speaks to the need for further knowledge mobilization.鈥�
THE WORK
SKIP鈥檚 associate scientific director, Dr. Katie Birnie (PhD 鈥�16), chaired the group that developed the new standard, recognized as the world鈥檚 first pain standard for children. As part of the recommendations, the standard acknowledges systemic factors such as racism and trauma that contribute to health inequities and exacerbate children鈥檚 pain.
With their evidence-based standard in hand, Dr. Chambers and the network of SKIP researchers, clinicians, patients, and other partners are now working with hospitals and institutions to adopt the standard that will acknowledge and help them relieve children鈥檚 pain. They are especially focused on outreach to community hospitals, where children receive the majority of their care, and healthcare professionals who see children there.
鈥淚t鈥檚 difficult for kids to get access to the interdisciplinary pain treatment that鈥檚 been shown to be effective in most people,鈥� Dr. Chambers says.
Dr. Chambers and Ms. Jordan want to make sure other children and families don鈥檛 experience the acute pain Alex suffered during and after surgery. Acute pain can set children up for chronic pain throughout their lives.
As the Strategic Lead, Patient Partnerships, Ms. Jordan brings other patient partners together to support Dr. Chambers鈥� projects, ensuring the direct experiences of children and youth and their families in coping with long-term pain inform the research and assist in disseminating knowledge about how to prevent and treat pain to professionals.
Those healthcare professionals need to treat pain as a patient safety issue, because when they don鈥檛 manage it, harmful effects result, Dr. Chambers says. Poorly managed, painful medical procedures are more likely to result in ongoing pain and complications, research indicates.
鈥淲hat we now know from decades of research in animals and in humans is that poorly managed pain early in life actually changes the way you experience pain (forever),鈥� she says.
THE IMPACT
In addition to their work on the national pain standard, Dr. Chambers and SKIP have produced and promoted 350 tools on pediatric pain management, held more than 450 consultations with hospitals and practitioners wanting to better manage children鈥檚 pain, and supported several children鈥檚 hospitals in Canada to achieve ChildKind certification.
ChildKind International offers certification to healthcare facilities that have demonstrated their excellence in assessing, preventing, and treating children鈥檚 pain.
The IWK Health Centre in Halifax received its ChildKind certification earlier this year 鈥� one of only five children鈥檚 hospitals in Canada to have it. The hospita is also working towards meeting any applicable recommendations in the Pediatric Pain Management Standard, says Dr. Krista Jangaard, the IWK鈥檚 president and chief executive officer.
The hospital works closely with Dr. Chambers and SKIP, and says the organization鈥檚 impact is not only national but global.
鈥淪KIP has done a huge amount within the pediatric world to put this as an issue on the table,鈥� Dr. Jangaard says.
The combination of ChildKind Certification and the hospital鈥檚 support for the pain standard means children and families coming to the IWK now encounter a more consistent culture of care, with many staff members trained to anticipate, prevent, treat, and manage pain, Dr. Jangaard says.
When a baby in the neonatal intensive care unit at IWK requires a needle stick, for example, nurses offer them sucrose, which calms and distracts them from pain, or staff encourage their mothers to breast-feed and cuddle them during the procedure 鈥� all practices designed to reduce babies鈥櫬� discomfort.
鈥淗ere at IWK Health we鈥檝e always been big champions of the fact that pain can be managed in children, it can be avoided, and it can be treated,鈥� Dr. Jangaard says.
Thanks to the new pain standard, 鈥渘ow we know everybody will be called to live up to the same [national] standards in taking care of kids,鈥� she adds.
At Alex鈥檚 last interaction with another pediatric hospital, close to 15 years after doctors removed the tumour, an anesthesiologist refused to provide pain relief for an IV insertion before Alex鈥檚 imaging appointment, Ms. Jordan says.
鈥淐ertainly, there are areas in that hospital where there is a [positive] change but seeing an overall systemic change to make managing children鈥檚 pain crucially important鈥攖hat鈥檚 where we need to go,鈥� Ms. Jordan says.
Because Ms. Jordan had worked with Dr. Chambers and knew 聽the new Pediatric Pain Management Standard existed, she and Tyler could advocate for the pain relief Alex required. They鈥檙e hopeful SKIP鈥檚 tools will empower more families and the new pain standard will ensure more hospitals and clinicians adopt the highest standards in pain management.
The next step, Dr. Chambers says, is to convince organizations to incorporate core aspects of the Pediatric Pain Management Standard into their accreditation processes.
鈥淓verything we do to manage pain is so important,鈥� says Dr. Chambers. 鈥淲e鈥檙e all about moving research into practice and policies and making a difference.鈥�